Personal Development
Self-Assessments: Examples and Guide for Managers and ...

Self-Assessments: Examples and Guide for Managers and ...

Shiken premium Upgrade Banner

Gaining Insight Through Self-Evaluations for Managers and Employees

Self-evaluation is an important part of personal and professional growth. It allows individuals to identify and explore their strengths and areas of need for development, which can help them to better their performance and decision-making. According to a Gallup study, those who do engage in self-assessments have higher wellbeing and experience greater personal growth. In light of this, self-assessments are becoming an increasingly valuable part of a company's overall performance management strategy.

In the current climate, employers are facing challenges on how to boost employee performance. While some may opt for hiring freezes or layoffs, businesses should consider the potential of self-assessments to bring out the best in their workers. Read on to learn more about the benefits of self-evaluations for both employers and employees, plus how to implement effective and impactful reviews.

What is a Self-Assessment?

Generally, a self-assessment is a performance review or evaluation which begins with feedback from the employer about the employee's progress. It then culminates with the employee's own assessment of their accomplishments in a given time period.

8 Benefits of Self-Evaluations for Managers and Employees

Self-assessments offer a variety of advantages to both employers and employees, helping to increase performance, development, and engagement. Here are eight benefits of self-evaluations:

  • Enhanced Performance. Research has found that self-assessments can lead to improved performance and self-directed learning skills. By offering employees the chance to reflect on and identify areas of need, performance can be positively impacted.
  • Greater Employee Engagement. Managers have the power to affect the employee experience significantly, with Gallup estimating that managers can account for up to 70% of employee engagement. Self-assessments help to encourage open and transparent communication between manager and employee, which can increase engagement.
  • Improved Decision-Making. With self-assessments, managers can quickly and accurately gain an understanding of their employees' capabilities. This can allow for improved decision-making when it comes to assigning tasks and allocating resources.
  • Effective Goal-Setting. Making sure that employees are aware of expectations and know what they should be striving to achieve is key. Self-assessments can aid in helping employees formulate goals and development plans.
  • Greater Accountability. By having to reflect on their performance and provide feedback to the employer, employees become more conscious of their own progress, leading to increased accountability.
  • Enhanced Job Satisfaction. Identifying areas for growth and having the support to make improvements can increase job satisfaction. Self-assessments provide employees with the tools they need to do this.
  • Motivation. By taking part in self-assessments, employees can develop a better understanding of their value and contribution to their organization, which can lead to increased motivation and job satisfaction.
  • Opportunity for Growth. Self-assessments ultimately give employees the opportunity to grow and become better at what they do. By reflecting on areas of need and developing strategies for improvement, employees can make more of an impact at their workplace.

What is a Self-Assessment and How Can It Help Managers and Employees?

Self-assessments are a useful tool for both managers and employees to gain insight into one another. Through self-assessments, managers can determine the goals and ambitions of their employees, as well as their strengths and weaknesses in the workplace.

The Benefits of Self-Assessments

Self-assessments can be a powerful tool for employees in order to gain a higher degree of self-awareness and self-reflection. Gaining this invaluable insight allows employees to identify areas for improvement, take ownership of their professional development, and recognize their own strengths. At Shiken, our Whole Person Model has been proven to bring 172% increase in self-awareness, even for those who start off low. To ensure that this self-assessment process is effective, there is key information to bear in mind.

How to Leverage a Self-Assessment

Self-assessments can act as a mirror, allowing employees to recognize what they excel in and which areas of their skill set need more focus. By taking ownership of this process, employees can determine the areas they should be developing professionally in order to bring the best value to the company. In addition, this can provide the opportunity to boost morale as employees may eventually recognize strengths that they had not previously been aware of. An example of this would be an employee being able to identify gaps in their project management knowledge, which can then be addressed with a project management workshop.

Questions for Self-Assessment

In order to gain the most from a self-assessment, it is important to ask the employee some pertinent questions. Examples would be:

  • When do you feel the most valued by the company?
  • What qualities of yours make you a valuable employee?
  • Which five things do you do that positively impact your productivity?
  • Are there any weaknesses that could be hampering your productivity?
  • Do you ask for help if a problem arises at work?
  • How could you work towards improving work-related opportunities?
  • What can leadership do to support you in addressing these opportunities?

Responding to Self-Evaluation Responses

Once an employee has responded to the self-assessment questions, it is important to provide them with tailored feedback to address their specific strengths and weaknesses. This will provide an employee with a better understanding of their situation and clarity when progressing their professional development. As an example, if an employee states that they are an excellent leader, the feedback can be to continue the great work and to keep reaching for new heights. Conversely, if the employee identifies an area for improvement, then the feedback should be specific on how this can be achieved.


Self-assessments can be an incredibly valuable tool for both employees and employers, as it provides a robust process of self-reflection, identifying areas of improvement, and determining the most appropriate areas for professional development. Most importantly, it helps employees to recognize their own strengths, potentially increasing morale and setting the conditions for professional success.

Self-Evaluation Responses on Growth and Development

I am proud to have grown as a leader throughout the past year and am looking forward to continuing my progress. It's clear that I am aware of my strengths and weaknesses, and motivated to work on them. Manager feedback is helpful in recognizing when I am making progress and gaining insight into how I can keep doing better.

I recently set the goal to become more organized and manage my time more effectively. Throughout the process, I am trying to learn from my mistakes and stay productive. My manager has commended me for taking responsibility and improving upon any mistakes that I have made.

Self-Assessment Responses on Advancing My Role

When I accepted my current role, I had the long-term goal of becoming a manager in the future. I think I have the necessary skills and capabilities to successfully lead a team; I have strong organizational skills, the ability to delegate tasks, and efficient time management. I also take great pride in pushing my colleagues to reach their fullest potential and think of innovative solutions to every project.

My manager has been encouraging me to keep striving for excellence and achieve the role I have envisioned for myself. It's important to me that I demonstrate transparency and kindheartedness towards my colleagues, while also remaining respectful when having difficult conversations with my managers.

Self-Assessment Responses on Time Management

Through my experience at the company, I have become confident in taking the creative initiative for upcoming projects. My lateral thinking skills have been praised in the past and my peers often come to me for guidance. I communicate progress (or lack thereof) to my colleagues, as well as my manager, and I am always open to giving and receiving feedback.

I am known for submitting work ahead of schedule and my organizational skills have been a great asset to the team. I have been asked for advice on how to effectively manage one's time and am always happy to share solutions. Additionally, I have learnt that it is important to tell my manager that I am already maxed out with projects and require help if I am ever at risk of missing a deadline.

A Few Tips on Writing a Self-Assessment

To create an effective self-assessment, it is important to remain honest and provide solutions for improvement. Acknowledge your successes and reflect on failures, but also ensure that your tone is professional throughout. Additionally, provide clarity on how you have gone above and beyond for the job, as well as what you are still working on. Self-assessments can be a great opportunity to show your growth and development as an individual and employee.

Professional Development Through Self-Assessment

In the professional world, taking responsibility for oneself and improving upon weaknesses is paramount for success. To maximize the potential of their workforce and build better teamwork, employers should ensure that their employees take the self-assessment process seriously. This article will discuss the importance of self-reflection, preparation for self-assessment, and other areas of development to consider.

Preparing for Self-Assessment

Self-assessment is a great way for employees to assess their strengths and weaknesses in order to effectively engage in self-directed learning and decision-making. Before a self-assessment session, managers should be aware of an employee's goals and areas of improvement. Additionally, tracking accomplishments throughout the year is a good way to showcase one's value to the company. It is advisable to keep a journal or notebook of notes regarding successful areas of work in order to remind employers of their contributions.

Maintaining a Professional Atmosphere

When providing a self-assessment, it is important to make sure that the evaluation is professional and not personal in nature. All employees have strengths and weaknesses, so it is important to emphasize any development initiatives that you wish to undertake. Showing a genuine interest in growing professionally will be well-received by employers, and will likely result in a positive evaluation.

Areas to Consider for Professional Development

  • Self-motivation and its use to reach goals
  • Performance review questions and their applications
  • Soft skills for leadership and employees
  • Positive affirmations to combat imposter syndrome
  • Developing self-knowledge: You 2.0
  • Paths to self-actualization

When providing a self-assessment, having concrete numbers and metrics is important in order to back up any claims of success. This sort of data-driven assessment allows employers to accurately measure progress and better prepare the workforce for the future.

Join Shiken For FREE

AI-powered learning tools. Create, relax, learn.

Gumbo Study Buddy

Try Shiken Premium
for Free

14-day free trial. Cancel anytime.
Get Started
Join 20,000+ learners worldwide.
The first 14 days are on us
96% of learners report x2 faster learning
Free hands-on onboarding & support
Cancel Anytime