Personal Development
How to Give and Take Constructive Criticism (With Examples)

How to Give and Take Constructive Criticism (With Examples)

Shiken premium Upgrade Banner

The Art of Constructive Criticism: Delivering and Receiving Feedback

Constructive criticism is essential for professional growth and improved performance. Offering and accepting criticism can be intimidating, but it is a necessary part of developing professionally. This article will discuss the art of constructive criticism, explain the differences between constructive and destructive criticism, the benefits of constructive feedback, how to give and receive constructive criticism, and how to avoid mistakes.

What is Constructive Criticism?

Constructive criticism is a type of feedback that is focused on actionable suggestions and recommendations for improvement. It provides the recipient with context for why the feedback is being provided, and outlines steps that can be taken for further development. It is designed to foster a positive and supportive work environment, where questions can be asked and help is available.

Constructive vs. Destructive Criticism

The primary distinction between constructive and destructive criticism is how it is delivered. Constructive criticism is clear and direct, providing specific advice on how to improve, and offering support and guidance for making those changes. Destructive criticism, on the other hand, is not actionable, and can reduce morale and confidence instead of building it up.

Benefits of Constructive Criticism

Constructive criticism offers great opportunities for both parties to grow and strengthen trust. It can provide detailed insight into areas for improvement, and open the door to conversations, collaboration, and professional development.

The Role of Empathy and Constructive Criticism

Empathy is an important part of constructive criticism. When delivering feedback, focus on the recipient's strengths and positive aspects of their work, provide constructive criticism in detail, and end with a positive statement to reiterate the initial encouraging sentiments. This will help create an atmosphere of trust and confidence.

Giving and Receiving Constructive Criticism

When offering constructive criticism, it is important to remain professional and respectful. Focus on positive outcomes and avoid any kind of negativity. The recipient should remain open-minded, take it as an opportunity to grow, and ask questions to understand the feedback and the desired changes better.

When receiving constructive criticism, it is essential to stay mindful of the other person's perspective. Avoid getting defensive and instead focus on hearing out the other person. Do not hesitate to ask for suggestions and advice, and thank the other person for taking the time to provide feedback.

The Dos and Don'ts of Constructive Criticism

To make sure constructive criticism is delivered and received correctly, here are some helpful dos and don'ts:

  • Do start with positives, focus on actionable advice, and be clear and polite.
  • Do emphasize the desired outcome and offer support.
  • Don't be vague, intimidating, or demotivating.
  • Don't forget to be empathetic and stay respectful.

What is Constructive Criticism?

Constructive criticism is an essential tool for helping people grow professionally and fostering development. When it is correctly given and received, it can strengthen relationships, build trust, and create opportunities for positive change. It is important to ensure that criticism is balanced with understanding and empathy for it to be effective, and that the manner in which it is delivered is critical.

Benefits of Giving Constructive Criticism

Recommending what someone can do to improve at work has a range of advantages, like promoting better recognition of expectations between the giver and receiver, serving as a catalyzer for an actionable plan, and inspiring the receiver to do something without procrastinating. To ensure the conversation is productive, it is important to prevent any attempts at jumping to conclusions and observe instead. Unreasonable assumptions can be taken as personal attacks and can be damaging for the workplace.

The art of giving constructive criticism is an ability that requires practice and empathy. To foster a culture of improvement, growth, and mutual respect when offering constructive feedback, these 13 recommendations should be observed:

  • Focus on conduct not the person. Criticism ought to concentrate on tangible actions or behaviors rather than identity, personality, or motivations.
  • Consider giving criticism in real-time. Feedback is more effective when given immediately, while all parties still have the events fresh in their minds. You do not always have to wait for your next one-on-one meeting.
  • Be aware of timing. If you or the receiver are coming from a heated debate, for instance, wait until things have settled down to keep the conversation constructive.
  • Consider emotions. It is advantageous to offer feedback when the other person is prepared to receive it. Refrain from giving criticism when the individual is incapable of hearing potentially unpleasant news.
  • Avoid workplace gossip. Gossiping can be damaging to all involved. It weakens trust at all levels. Keep all feedback between you and the recipient, and make sure they are informed first.
  • Focus on the scenario not the person. Constructive criticism should focus on the behavior you want to see more of rather than what you noted and did not enjoy.
  • Employ the "I" language technique. This technique helps the recipient of the criticism comprehend that the criticism is about the situation and not about their person. It also validates your point of view and allows the receiver know how the situation is seen.
  • Stay objective. Concentrate more on objective points rather than subjective opinions. Instead of saying 'I do not like it,' specify the particular aspects you do not like (e.g., the purple lettering on a yellow background made my eyes hurt).
  • Keep communication clear. Split your feedback into core points or themes for improved clarity before discussing them one by one. Refrain from giving your feedback in one large lump.
  • Provide specific examples for each point. Point out one or two exact scenarios where the person has displayed the behaviors you want them to change. This assists to (a) demonstrate what you mean and (b) raise the person's awareness of behavior patterns that they may not recognize.
  • Offer usable solutions. Alongside recognizing areas for enhancement, suggest practical steps or strategies which can help the recipient address the issues efficiently.
  • Maintain a constructive tone. Utilize language that is respectful, supportive, and non-confrontational. Frame your criticism in a positive light, emphasizing growth and development.
  • Leave room for questions. Giving constructive criticism can make both parties uneasy. And comments can be misunderstood or misinterpreted. Make sure to leave space and time for questions to ensure everyone is on the same page.

Things to Avoid When Giving Constructive Criticism

When giving constructive criticism, it is important to avoid certain behaviors that can impede the dialogue. These include: personal attacks, assumptions, overwhelming the receiver with criticism, withholding compliments, and using derogatory language or making disparaging comments.

How to Receive Constructive Criticism

It can be a tricky situation when the tables turn and you are on the receiving end of constructive criticism. It can be difficult to remain open-minded and remember that the feedback is not a personal judgment, but an opportunity to improve and grow in certain areas. Here are some tips for how to better absorb constructive criticism:

  • View feedback as an opportunity for learning and growth - Reframe the way you think about criticism and see it as a method for growth rather than an attack.
  • Be open-minded - Remain open-minded to the feedback and fight off the temptation to feel defensive.
  • Ask questions - If anything is unclear, seek clarification to make sure you understand the point being made.
  • Show appreciation - Criticism is an indication that someone cares about your development.
  • Take your time - Take the appropriate amount of time to process and evaluate the feedback you receive. Consider keeping a journal to aid in this process.
  • Follow up - Follow up with the person who provided the feedback to show that you took their advice into consideration.

Applied in the right manner, constructive criticism can be a great tool for self-assessment and development. Whether giving or receiving criticism, the goal should always be to establish a culture of growth, improvement, and mutual respect.

Receiving Criticism with Tact and Grace

It is important to remember that constructive criticism can come from fallible sources. While criticism can be hard to take in, there is a way to receive it with tact and grace and even use to your advantage. Here is a 7-step process for doing so:

  • Suppress your first reaction - Maintain composure and don't react to the criticism. Remember that there are many benefits to receiving feedback and attempt to understand the perspective of your criticizer.
  • Be an attentive listener - Listen closely to the criticism and focus on understanding the other person's comments and viewpoint.
  • Say thank you - Express your gratitude to show that you understand the effort being put in to help you improve.
  • Take time for reflection - Give yourself time to process the criticism and think about how you can use it to better your performance. This will help foster self-awareness and lead to more growth.
  • Ask questions - Deconstruct the feedback, acknowledge the indisputable parts, and ask for concrete examples or solutions.
  • Request a follow-up - If the issue is important, ask to have a follow-up meeting to ask further questions and decide on next steps. This will enable you to process the feedback and come up with solutions.
  • Show future plans and thank the person again - Express your thanks to encourage the continued giving of feedback in the future.

Feedback from a trusted and unbiased source is invaluable, however, certain reactions can make people less eager to give feedback in the future. To ensure that feedback will continue to come, avoid the following five reactions:

  • Defensiveness or anger
  • Attacking the person who is giving the feedback
  • Interrupting or talking over the person
  • Analyzing or questioning the person's assessment initially
  • Engaging in a debate or a combative response

Criticism is not an easy pill to swallow, but with the proper approach, it can be used to sharpen performance and build relationships. It is important to offer constructive feedback that is actionable, specific, and related to the context.

Providing constructive feedback

Constructive feedback is an important tool for developing employees and building meaningful relationships. It requires empathy and kindness, as well as careful consideration of one's own emotions, in order to provide feedback effectively.

7 Steps for Effective Feedback

  • Focus on the growth mindset
  • Be kind and empathetic
  • Stay aware of your emotions
  • Express your feedback constructively
  • Avoid being overly critical
  • Provide positive feedback in addition to criticism
  • Learn from the feedback process

5 Reactions to Avoid

  • Demeaning comments
  • Jokes and sarcasm
  • Being overly harsh
  • Being overly positive
  • Focusing on the individual rather than the behavior

16 Constructive Feedback Examples

The following are a few examples of how one can provide constructive feedback:

  • Express appreciation for their efforts
  • Identify specific areas of improvement
  • Make constructive rather than destructive criticism
  • Be clear and succinct
  • Help the employee find solutions to the problem
  • Encourage the employee to practice self-reflection
  • Define specific, achievable goals
  • Explain the impact of their behavior
  • Recognize their successes
  • Set clear expectations
  • Show them how to effectively resolve challenges
  • Be open to their feedback as well
  • Request their ideas and solutions
  • Focus on solutions rather than dwelling on the problem
  • Explain the potential consequences of their actions
  • Offer support and resources

By following this process and avoiding the reactions listed above, you can unlock the potential of your people and build meaningful relationships. With these constructive feedback examples, you can start giving effective feedback today.

Join Shiken For FREE

AI-powered learning tools. Create, relax, learn.

Gumbo Study Buddy

Try Shiken Premium
for Free

14-day free trial. Cancel anytime.
Get Started
Join 20,000+ learners worldwide.
The first 14 days are on us
96% of learners report x2 faster learning
Free hands-on onboarding & support
Cancel Anytime